Thursday 31 October 1918 – Greg’s Last CBP of the War

Today was, in retrospect at least, a significant day: the counter-battery patrol that Greg flew was to be his last of the war.  It was also Greg’s last wartime flight for which we have an entry in the Squadron Record Books for 42 Squadron.

Log Book

Log BookLog Book

Date: 31.10.18 
Time Out: 8.00 
Rounds Fired – Lewis: - 
Rounds Fired – Vickers: - 
Bombs: 4 
Time on RE8s:  182 hrs 55 mins 
RE8: 2517 
Observer: Mulholland 
War Flying: 2 hrs 35 mins 
Height: 3000 
Course/Remarks:  C.B.P.  6 Huns.  Fokkers.

Squadron Record Book

Squadron Record Book
Click for larger image.
Type and Number: R.E.8.2517
Pilot and Observer: P. Lt Gregory. O. Lt Mulholland
Duty: Artillery Patrol
Hour of Start: 0800
Hour of Return: 1035.
Remarks: 0820. Large fire and numerous explosions at D.B. zone.  The fires were continuous for about 2 hours, and covered a large area.
0915. Large explosion at V.C. zone. Probably ammunition.
0930. Slight enemy shelling at PONT A CHIN, unable to pick up flashes.
E.K.B. 0815. 1 at 3000’ over J.18.  Pulled down at 0840 and let up again at 0920.
E.A. Six Fokkers at 4000’ over I.&.O. squares.  Sent 6.F.E.A.I.4. [Six Fokker enemy aircraft over I.4.]
BOMBS. 4-25 lb dropped at I.38.a. [Looks like 38, but can’t be, as the numbering only goes up to 36]  Four bursts observed.
Vis. fair to bad.  Height 3000’.  Obs.by P.&.O.

The activity seen on this patrol was all to the north and northeast of Tournai:

Map showing events of 31 October 1918, north to northeast of Tournai.
Map showing events of 31 October 1918, north to northeast of Tournai. Adapted from 1:40,000 scale maps. Each lettered square is 6,000 yards,and each numbered square is 1,000 yards. Click for larger image. Map credit IWM/TNA/Great War Digital. Image of Kite Balloon adapted from IWM photo Q11901.

V.C. Zone

There is a bit of ambiguity about which V.C. zone the Squadron Record Book (SRB) report is referring to.  V.C. zone refers to the bottom left quadrant of V square.  The V.C. zone that I have shown on the above map extract is from V square of 1:40,000 Map Sheet 29, which is just to the north of Sheet 37.  Sheet 37 covers Tournai and surrounding areas and has its own V square, and hence its own V.C. zone, though.  For each map sheet, V square is immediately below P square, and hence for Sheet 37 it is southeast of Tournai.

The SRB entries rarely said which map sheet they were referring to.  (Those who wrote them and read them all knew what they meant).  I have assumed that V square and V.C. zone of Sheet 29 was what was meant here, on the basis that V.C. and D.B. zones, where similar activity was reported, touch each other.

Six Fokkers

The six Fokkers were over squares I and O.  The specific subsquare that formed the basis of Greg’s zone call (“6.F.E.A.I.4“) was I.4, which borders square C.  The River Scheldt (Escaut in French) as it ran north of Tournai from square O to square I formed the British front line at the time.

Four Bombs Dropped at I.38.a?

Well, they can’t have been!  Although the entry seems clear, there isn’t a quadrant 38.a.  Each lettered square is made up of a six-by-six array of subsquares, which are numbered 1 to 36.  And each numbered square is divided into four quadrants a, b, c and d, with quadrant a being the top left. So 38.a just isn’t possible.

What might have been intended? Here is a larger scale extract, from a 1:20,000 map, showing the bottom 12 subsquares of square I:

Map showing Pont-à-Chin, north of Tournai
Map showing Pont-à-Chin, north of Tournai. Adapted from a 1:20,000 scale map. Each numbered square is 1,000 yards. Click for larger image. Map credit IWM/TNA/Great War Digital.

Any of quadrants 28.a30.a33.a and 36.a might have been intended, as they were all to the east of the River Scheldt and hence the British front line.  

Last Counter Battery Patrol

Today’s counter-battery patrol was Greg’s last.  (One was scheduled for 3 November 1918, but the weather put paid to it.)  Undertaking these patrols had been one of his two main jobs with 42 Squadron, the other being the observation of artillery fire, or ‘shoots’. The first CPB was on 13 June 1918, the week after Greg joined the squadron at Rely:

Thursday 13 June 1918 – CBP and ‘Archie’

Today is the 46th entry in his log book for a counter-battery patrol. To see the whole collection, click here.  And for a refresher of what they were all about, have a look at this page:

Counter Battery Patrols and Zone Calls

Although this was Greg’s last counter-battery patrol, there was still much to do before the fighting was over.

Last Flight with Lt. Mulholland

Today was also Greg’s last flight with Lt Arthur Mulholland, with whom he had previously flown on 12 September 1918 and 15 September 1918.  The 12 September post contains a profile of Lt. Mulholland.

Last wartime SRB entry

And on the subject of ‘lasts’, today is also the last day for which a pre-armistice Squadron Record Book entry for 42 Squadron RAF is available.  That isn’t to say that there never were any entries.  It’s just that they’re missing from the files of The National Archives.

The Squadron Record Books for 42 Squadron RAF for late 1918 are held in two files at The National Archives.  They are AIR/1/1840/204/209/10 (July to November 1918):

Cover for file AIR/1/1840/204/209/10 at The National Archives.
Cover for file AIR/1/1840/204/209/10 at The National Archives. Click for larger image.

and AIR/1/1416/204/29/9(1) (1 July 1918 to 8 February 1919):

Cover for file AIR/1/1416/204/29/9(1) at The National Archives
Cover for file AIR/1/1416/204/29/9(1) at The National Archives. Click for larger image.

The two files contain duplicates of some records.  Often duplicates are just carbon copies of different quality.  Unfortunately, neither file contains any records covering the almost three weeks from 1 to 19 November 1918. And, to be honest, the subsequent SRB entries are pretty dull.  They’re mostly such things as rigging tests and travelling flights.

If anyone finds copies of the missing entries, or knows something of their whereabouts if they’re still extant, please do get in touch via the contact page.  The National Archives would probably be glad to hear from you too. 

 

Tuesday 29 October 1918 – Reconn. to Tournai and Beyond

It was billed as a counter-battery patrol in the log book, and as reconnaissance in the Squadron Record Book.  In fact it was both.  After a misty false start, today’s patrol took Greg further east into Belgium than he had gone before. There were three German Fokkers over Mont St. Aubert, heading north from Tournai.  But the mist made artillery flashes hard to pinpoint.

Log Book

Log BookLog Book

Date: 29.10.18 
Time Out: 6.20/7.00 
Rounds Fired – Lewis: 100 
Rounds Fired – Vickers: - 
Bombs: 4 
Time on RE8s:  180 hrs 20 mins 
RE8: 2517 
Observer: Scarterfield 
War Flying: 1 hrs 35 mins 
Height: 3000 
Course/Remarks:  C.B.P.  3 Huns.  Fokkers.

Squadron Record Book

Squadron Record Book
Click for larger image.
Type and Number: R.E.8.2517
Pilot and Observer: P. Lt Gregory. O. Lt Scarterfield
Duty: Test Flight.
Hour of Start: 0620.
Hour of Return: 0640.
Remarks: Weather test.
Visibility very poor. -ground mist.
Squadron Record Book
Click for larger image.
Type and Number: R.E.8.2517
Pilot and Observer: P. Lt Gregory. O. Lt Scarterfield
Duty: Reconnaissance
Hour of Start: 0700
Hour of Return: 0815
Remarks: 0720. M.G. fire drawn from J.29.b.5.4.
0725. Enemy shelling road and railway crossing at H.30.c.8.2. Unable to see flashes owing to mist.
0740. Sent K.K. on flashes in J.35. Too misty to pinpoint.
E.A. 0750. 1.E.A. at 4000’ over D.C. zone.
0755. 3.Fokkers at 5000’ over I.D. proceeding Northwards.
BRIDGES. still intact at TOURNAI with the exception of railway bridge at O.6.d.2.8. [Probably O.16.d.2.8 intended]
  Traffic bridge at O.10.a.1.1 intact
  Foot bridges at I.32.a.5.5.  I.26.b.9.9.  I.14.b.8.7.  still passable.
A.A. Normal.
E.K.B. Nil.
BOMBS.4-25lb dropped at I.29.d.5.0.  Bursts observed.
Vis.V.Poor.  Height 1500/2500’.  Obs.by P.&.O.

This map shows the sites of most of the observations:

Map showing events of 29 October 1918, north of Tournai.
Map showing events of 29 October 1918, north of Tournai. Adapted from a 1:40,000 scale map. Each numbered square is 1,000 yards. Click for larger image. Map credit IWM/TNA/Great War Digital.

Zone DC

Zone DC, above which Greg saw one Fokker, is from 2-5,000 yds north of sub-squares 13, 14 and 15 of square J.

Mont St. Aubert

The three Fokkers seen above zone ID were flying northwards above Mont St. Aubert, a hilly outcrop 3½ miles (5.5 km) north of Tournai.  The hills reach above the 140m contour line and were to form part of a short-lived defensive line held by the retreating German army.

Railway Bridge

The Squadron Record Book (SRB) refers to a no longer intact railway bridge at O.6.d.2.8, but there is no railway in or near sub-square O.6.  However, the railway bridge at O.16.d.2.8 is the principal railway bridge over the Scheldt coming northwest out of Tournai, and look likely to have been a prime candidate for destruction by the withdrawing German forces.

Traffic Bridge

It is not clear what is meant by the (intact) traffic bridge at O.10.a.1.1, as no bridge is shown at that point. But it is possible that one had been built after the map (dated March 1917) was drawn.  At this point, the main stream of the river is by-passing Lock No. 2 (Écluse No. 2) so it is possible that the river was at least temporarily bridged here.

“Pinpoint”

Greg says in the SRB that it was “too misty to pinpoint” the flashes in J.35.  This isn’t the first time he has said “pinpoint”, either as one word or two.  See the SRB entries in the post for 8 October 1918 and 25 October 1918.  Although the word is in common usage today, what’s interesting is that 100 years ago it wasn’t.  As the following Google Ngram View shows, its usage really took off between the 1940s and 1980s, since when it has declined a little.  And up to the mid 1930s “pinpoint” and “pin point” were used more or less equally – if rarely.

 Google Ngram for “pinpoint”.  Click here for a full version.

Next up…

The next entry in Greg’s log book is for Thursday 31 October 1918.

Saturday 26 October 1918 – Prop. Split by Shrapnel

Squadron Record Book extract

Two attempts at photography today.  The first, in cloudy conditions in the morning, was unsuccessful.  The second was a success, with at least 20 plates exposed of the River Scheldt, north of Tournai.  But success was accompanied by a narrow escape, as shrapnel from anti-aircraft fire split the propeller of RE8 2517.  Fortunately, Greg and his observer Lt John Macmillan were able to return safely to the aerodrome at Ascq.

Log Book

Log BookLog Book

Date: 26.10.18 
Time Out: 9.45 
Rounds Fired – Lewis: - 
Rounds Fired – Vickers: - 
Bombs: - 
Time on RE8s:  178 hrs 05 mins 
RE8: 2517 
Observer: McMillan [sic, should be Macmillan]
War Flying: 0 hrs 50 mins 
Height: 3000 
Course/Remarks:  Photos – too cloudy.
Date: 26.10.18 
Time Out: 12.20 
Rounds Fired – Lewis: - 
Rounds Fired – Vickers: - 
Bombs: - 
Time on RE8s:  178 hrs 45 mins 
RE8: 2517 
Observer: McMillan [sic, should be Macmillan]
War Flying: 0 hrs 40 mins 
Height: 3500 
Course/Remarks:  Photos – 20 plates.

Although the log book gives little in the way of detail, there is more in the Squadron Record Book:

Squadron Record Book

Squadron Record Book
Click for larger image.
Type and Number: R.E.8.2517
Pilot and Observer: P. Lt Gregory. O. Lt McMillan [sic, should be Macmillan]
Duty: Photography
Hour of Start: 0945, 1220
Hour of Return: 1035, 1300
Remarks: 1240. 12 24 plates exposed over I.A. & I.C. zones from 3500’.
A.A. [Anti-aircraft fire] Accurate, apparently at long range. (Propellor split by shrapnel.)
E.A. [Enemy aircraft] Nil.
Vis.Good.Clouds 3700’.  Height 3500’.  Obs.by P.&.O.

IA and IC Zones

Zones IA and IC together form the left hand (west) side of square I on map sheet 37.  They cover the River Scheldt a few miles north of Tournai.  Pont-à-Chin, the scene of yesterday’s patrol, is at the bottom of zone IC, and Pecq is at the top of zone IA:

Map showing zones photographed on 26 October 1918
Map showing zones photographed on 26 October 1918, north of Tournai. Adapted from a 1:40,000 scale map. Each numbered square is 1,000 yards. Click for larger image. Map credit IWM/TNA/Great War Digital.

Propeller Split

Shrapnel from anti-aircraft fire (‘archie’) hit the propeller of the aircraft and split it.  The RE8’s propeller was of laminated hardwood construction, which probably limited the damage to a split. The laminations can be seen in this photograph of the RAF Museum’s replica RE8 built by The Vintage Aviator Limited of New Zealand:

Replica RE8 at Hendon
Propeller and engine detail of the replica RE8 A3930 at the RAF Museum, Hendon. Click or tap to see full size image.  

In the event, the damage wasn’t so severe as to prevent the aircraft being flown back to Ascq.  Nonetheless, it was certainly a case of: Archibald, certainly hot – as the song almost had it!

Thursday 13 June 1918 – CBP and ‘Archie’

Lt John Gibb Brown Macmillan

Greg’s observer today was Lt John Gibb Brown Macmillan. Both Greg’s log book and the Squadron Record book spell his name as McMillan.  But when Lt Macmillan signed his name on the front of the menu of the Farewell Dinner to mark the squadron’s departure from Rely on 10 October 1918, he unmistakably wrote ‘Macmillan’.  See the post containing the menu here (Macmillan’s signature is above the girl’s cap):

Thursday 10 October 1918 – Rely Farewell Dinner

John Macmillan was born on 19 October 1898, and so had celebrated his 20th birthday exactly one week ago. Greg’s diary says nothing about him.  But the list of RFC/RAF people at airhistory.org.uk notes that on 29 June 1918 he suffered a forced landing with Lt Bill Ledlie at Créquy in RE8 C2478:

Ok [C2478 RE8] f/l Crequy due thick fog on artly patrol. Lt W Ledlie Ok/2Lt JGB Macmillan Ok

42 Squadron were operating out of Rely at the time, and Créquy is some 15 miles (24 km) southwest from Rely, towards the coast. The nearest point of the front line was 11 miles (18 km) in precisely the opposite direction. So presumably they had (seriously) overshot Rely in the fog on the way home.

The two flights today were to be the only ones in which Greg and Lt Macmillan flew together.

Next up…

The next entry in Greg’s log book is for Tuesday 29 October 1918.

Friday 25 October 1918 – First CPB from Ascq: Pont-à-Chin

Despite poor visibility, Greg and Lt Bett went on their first counter-battery patrol from Ascq. The patrol was short (45 mins) and low (700 ft). They reconnoitred the situation near Pont-à-Chin on the River Scheldt, north of Tournai.

Log Book

Log BookLog Book

Date: 25.10.18 
Time Out: 15.35 
Rounds Fired – Lewis: - 
Rounds Fired – Vickers: - 
Bombs: - 
Time on RE8s:  177 hrs 15 mins 
RE8: 2517 
Observer: Bett 
War Flying: 0 hrs 45 mins 
Height: 700 
Course/Remarks:  C.B.P. – Dud.

Squadron Record Book

Squadron Record Book
Click for larger image.
Type and Number: R.E.8.2517
Pilot and Observer: P. Lt Gregory. O. Lt Bett
Duty: Reconnaissance
Hour of Start: 1535
Hour of Return: 1620
Remarks: 1535. Enemy shelling PONT A CHIN village & “Y” roads at I.32.a.1.1.
Flashes seen in wood at I.30.a. & I.24.b.&.d. – impossible to pin point owing to visibility.  Flashes red.
Floods in I.33.& 27.  subsided.  Large floods still in I.21.
A.A.M.G. [anti-aircraft machine gun] & single rifle shots from O.4.
No new footbridges seen.
Bridges at I.32.a.7.2. destroyed.
No E.A. [enemy aircraft] or E.K.B. [enemy kite balloons] seen.
Vis. poor.  Height 700’.  Obs.by P.&.O.

The following map shows the locations referred to:

Map showing observations on reconnaissance patrol on 25 October 1918, Pont-à-Chin north of Tournai.
Map showing observations on reconnaissance patrol on 25 October 1918, north of Tournai. Adapted from a 1:40,000 scale map. Each numbered square is 1,000 yards. Click for larger image. Map credit IWM/TNA/Great War Digital.

Just one week ago, Greg reported on a reconnaissance flight from Chocques that the bridges over the River Escaut (Scheldt) north of Tournai were intact:

Friday 18 October 1918 – Reconnaissance into Belgium

That was no longer the case.  Today he reported: “Bridges at I.32.a.7.2. destroyed.”  This seems to have been the crossing over the Scheldt from Pont-à-Chin to Paradis.  Earlier in and probably before the war, there was a evidently a ferry over the river.  Leading east from the ferry, next to the Au Ponton du Paradis inn, was a bridged track or causeway over the marshes on the eastern bank to the settlement of Paradis.  The Germans had evidently built a bridge to replace the ferry, as shown overprinted in blue on the 1:20,000 scale map extract below, which was updated to October 1918.  But unsurprisingly they had destroyed it as they withdrew east across the river.

Bridges destroyed at Pont-à-Chin - map.
River crossing at Pont-à-Chin. Adapted from a 1:20,000 scale map marked ‘Trenches corrected from information received up to 15 .10.18’. Each numbered square is 1,000 yards. Click for larger image. Map credit IWM/TNA/Great War Digital.

Pont-à-Chin

Pont-à-Chin was one of the first crossing points on the River Scheldt north of the bridges in Tournai.  It still is today: apart from the A8-E42 autoroute crossing high above the river, the Pont Bolus at Pont-à-Chin in the first place going north of Tournai where a’surface road’ crosses the Scheldt.

This was not the first occasion on which war raged around the village.  In the Flanders campaign of the French Revolutionary Wars, the Battle of Tournai was fought on 22 May 1794.  Pont-à-Chin changed hands four times during the battle, which resulted in a victory for the allies of the coalition (Austrian, British and Hanoverian) forces of the ancien régime against the revolutionary French.  Times and allegiances change, even if the fields of battle don’t.  

 

Thursday 24 October 1918 – Weather Test: Dud

In a 10 minute flight with Lt Scarterfield for a weather test, the verdict brought back was:  dud.  

Log Book

Log BookLog Book

Date: 24.10.18 
Time Out: 7.10 
Rounds Fired – Lewis: - 
Rounds Fired – Vickers: - 
Bombs: - 
Time on RE8s:  176 hrs 30 mins 
RE8: 2517 
Observer: Scarterfield 
War Flying: 0 hrs 10 mins 
Height: 700 
Course/Remarks:  Weather test – Dud.

No more flying for Greg for the day.

Wednesday 23 October 1918 – Front Reaches River Scheldt

By the morning of Wednesday 23 October 1918, the British Front had reached the River Scheldt, north and south of Tournai.  The front was in the western outskirts of Tournai, but the city itself wasn’t yet in British hands.

Map showing that the British Front had reached the River Scheldt by the morning of 23 October 1918
The British Front had reached the River Scheldt by the morning of 23 October 1918. Adapted from a map accompanying General Haig’s despatches on the final British offensive. Click for larger image. Map credit: IWM/TNA/Great War Digital.

In the six days since 17 October 1918, the front had moved east by 15 miles (24 km).  This probably represented the most rapid advance by British troops on the Lys sector.

River Scheldt

The River Scheldt (Escaut in French, Schelde in Dutch)  rises at Gouy, near Le Cateau, in the Aisne département of France and flows north through Valenciennes (France) and Tournai (Belgium) to Ghent, where it is joined by the River Lys.  Thereafter it continues north to Antwerp, whose citizens it “connects with the rest of the world”, according to a former mayor.  After Antwerp it crosses the border into the Netherlands, and flows into the North Sea at Flushing (Vlissingen).

Tuesday 22 October 1918 – 42 Squadron RAF Moves to Ascq

In a vivid indication – if further indication were needed – of how fast the war was moving (and moving eastwards), 42 Squadron RAF was itself on the move again.  After a mere nine days in Chocques, the squadron today travelled the 25 miles (40.5 km) ENE to Ascq, just east of Lille.

Log Book

Log BookLog Book

Date: 22.10.18 
Time Out: 7.00 
Rounds Fired – Lewis: - 
Rounds Fired – Vickers: - 
Bombs: - 
Time on RE8s:  176 hrs 20 mins 
RE8: 2517 
Observer: Scarterfield 
War Flying: 0 hrs 25 mins 
Height: 1500 
Course/Remarks:  Travelling flight to Ascq.

Squadron Record Book

Squadron Record Book
Click for larger image.
Type and Number: R.E.8.27
Pilot and Observer: P. Lt Gregory. O. Lt Scarterfield
Duty: Travelling Flight.
Hour of Start: 0705
Hour of Return: 0735
Remarks: Travelling to new Aerodrome

This all looks fairly straightforward, until you consider which aeroplane Greg and Lt Scarterfield actually flew in.  Was it 2517, as in Greg’s log book, or E27, as in the Squadron Record Book?  Well, who knows.  But if the reconnaissance flight on Friday 18 October 1918 (link below) wasn’t Greg’s last flight in E27, then today’s travelling flight certainly was.

Friday 18 October 1918 – Reconnaissance into Belgium

From Artois to Flanders

Since 42 Squadron was deployed (as 42 Squadron RFC) to the Lys sector in March 1918, it has always operated out of aerodromes in the Pas-de-Calais département.  These were (with dates of arrival, which are linked to the relevant posts):

Artois

The flag of Artois
The flag of Artois. Credit Wikipedia User:Patricia.fidi

Chocques, Trèzennes and Rely aerodromes were in the sizeable central portion of the Pas-de-Calais that was the ancient County of Artois (Dutch Artesië, whence the English adjective artesian, as in well), of which the capital was Arras. 

Today was the day that 42 Squadron moved from Artois to Flanders – French Flanders, that is.

Map of 42 Squadron’s move ENE from Chocques to Ascq.
42 Squadron’s move ENE from Chocques to Ascq shown on a modern map (courtesy Google). Click for a larger, zoomable map (opens in new tab)

Flanders

Flag of Flanders
Flag of Flanders. Credit: Tom Lemmens (Wikipedia User:Tom-L)

Flanders was also an ancient (medieval) county whose territory is today in France and Belgium.  Lille (Dutch Reisel) is one of its major cities, and its principal domestic railway station is Lille Flandres.  Today, French Flanders is part of the Nord département. 

The old course of the River Lys, as it flowed from west to east near Merville, marked the boundary between the counties of Artois and Flanders.  It does the same job now, demarking the Pas-de-Calais and Nord départements.  In acknowledgement of the ancient boundary, the dykes forming the north and south banks of the canalised River Lys are today known as the Digue de Flandres and the the Digue d’Artois.  

Farewell to Chocques

Only having been in Chocques for just over a week, 42 Squadron barely had time to get their feet under the table.  It can’t have felt much like home in so short a time.  But Greg may have felt leaving Chocques to be significant for another reason.  It was here that he first saw and probably heard the effect of the artillery of the Western Front, as he travelled through on his way to Rely in early June 1918.  Chocques had been just 2½ miles from the front line:

Sunday 2 June 1918 – The Long Trail to Aire

Ascq

Ascq, where 42 Squadron was moving to, was a small settlement a couple of miles out into the countryside east of Lille, with a station on the railway line to Tournai.  Today, it still has the station, but it has grown into Villeneuve-d’Ascq, which is practically a city in its own right.  Villeneuve-d’Ascq is home to the  Université de Lille, Campus Cité Scientifique, and to the headquarters of the well known French supermarket Auchan. 

The site of the former aerodrome was south of the Rue des Fusilés (today the D941) and now accommodates a housing development.  It is shown here with a red flag in the bottom right quadrant of square R.15 (i.e. R.15.d) of a First World War 1:40,000 scale map, and correspondingly on a modern map:

Ascq (left centre) in the First World War.
Ascq, east of Lille, in the First World War. The airfield is in square R.15, marked with a red flag in the bottom right sub-square (d). Click for larger image. Map credit: TNA/IWM/Great War Digital.
Ascq, east of Lille, today
Ascq, east of Lille, today. A red flag again marks the airfield. Click for larger image. Map credit: IGN France/Great War Digital.

Zone Calls

The following zone calls are recorded in the Squadron Record Book today, together in each case with the word ‘Unobserved’.  Presumably other squadrons put out these calls, calling for artillery fire on what appeared to be urgent and high value targets. The zones in question were all to the east of Tournai.  But 42 Squadron was unable to observe the response to any of them as they were busy relocating to their new home, which was about 13 miles (21 km) miles to the west.

Squadron Record Book
Click for larger image.
Zone Calls.
P.C. G.F. TRAIN P.24.b.1.3     Unobserved
J.C. N.F. A.A. J.25.a.85.75         "
J.C. W.P. N.F. A.A. J.25.a          "
J.C. G.F. TRAIN J.31.d.2.6 W        "
J.C. G.F. TRAIN J.32.c.8.4 E        "
J.A. N.F. J.13.d.95.05              "

Translation Key:

  • P.C.J.C. and J.A. are all map zones northeast (J.A. and J.C.) and east (P.C.) of Tournai.
  • G.F.: Gun fire (or Fleeting target)
  • N.F.: Guns Now Firing in position at…
  • N.F.A.A.: Anti-aircraft ditto
  • W.P.N.F.: Many batteries in square active (followed by location of square)   
  • W travelling west
  • E travelling east

A Confusion of Zones

There’s something wrong with the first zone call (P.C. G.F. TRAIN P.24.b.1.3).  Map position P.24.b.1.3 isn’t in zone P.C.; rather, it is is zone P.D.  Which is wrong, the zone or the map reference?  Well, a railway passes through P.24.b.1.3, so perhaps P.D. G.F. TRAIN P.24.b.1.3 was intended.  But the same railway also passes through P.20.b.1.3, which is 4,000 yards to the west, in zone P.C.  So maybe P.C. G.F. TRAIN P.20.b.1.3 was intended.

No doubt this ambiguous error caused some cursing on the part of the battery artillery commanders, as well as a few wasted shells.  

A Bit of Light Exercise…

Armed with the above zone calls, the key, and knowledge of the above error, all that is needed to locate the targets on a map is, well, a map.  So here it is, and I’ve marked the relevant zones on it.  But the location of the targets is left as an exercise for the reader. (I’ve always wanted to write a sentence like that.)  Help is at hand – see the link below the map.

Map showing zones near Tournai.
Zones near Tournai. Adapted from a 1:40,000 scale map. Each numbered square is 1,000 yards. Click for larger image. Map credit IWM/TNA/GreatWarDigital.

Further information on map references and zone calls generally is available here:

Counter Battery Patrols and Zone Calls

Next Up…

The next entry in Greg’s log book is for Thursday 24 October 1918.

Friday 18 October 1918 – Reconnaissance into Belgium

Yesterday’s reconnaissance patrol was remarkable for being east of Lille. Today’s patrol was remarkable for how much further east it was: into Belgium, as far as the River Escaut.  And for encountering 10 Fokkers.  This was Greg’s last patrol in the RE8 serial No E27, which may have been named ‘Gwen’, at least by him.  Meanwhile, more British troops enter Lille.

Log Book

Log BookLog Book

Date: 18.10.18 
Time Out: 12.00 
Rounds Fired – Lewis: - 
Rounds Fired – Vickers: 100 
Bombs: - 
Time on RE8s:  175 hrs 55 mins 
RE8: E27 
Observer: Scarterfield 
War Flying: 2 hrs 20 mins 
Height: 3000 
Course/Remarks:  Reconn.  10 Huns.  Fokker biplanes.

Squadron Record Book

Type and Number: R.E.8.E27
Pilot and Observer: P. Lt Gregory. O. Lt Scarterfield
Duty: Reconnaissance
Hour of Start: 1200
Hour of Return: 1420
Remarks: Reconnaissance running along the railway running East from LILLE through M.13 - 18. N.13 - 15 – 12.
Flooded fields at G.32.
1245. Shelling at TEMPLEUVE (H.33). Large white bursts.
1245. Light engine with steam up stationary at N.15.c.0.7.
1250. Large fires in woods along railway at I.31.c.  Bridges along River ESCAUT all apparently intact and not damaged.
No enemy trenches were observed on the West side of l’ESCAUT River.
Enemy machine gun posts still in houses in village in L.24. & M.2.a.
1315. Heavy shelling of railway junction & FORT CROIX DE VALLERS (Shrapnel).
British cavalry seen in M.8.
Large bodies of British troops moving East, N.E. of LILLE towards BREUCQ. (L.15).
R.E.8. Numbered ‘3’ slightly crashed at L.13.b.9.9.
ROUBAIX station in G.3.a. on fire.
A.A. Fire not very accurate over M. & N. squares. Two bursts fired whilst flying at 1000’ over G.25.  Enemy tracers fired at machine whilst flying low over G.22. 23. 30. H.31. N.2. N.9.
E.A. 1300. Large formation of ten Fokker Biplanes flying west at about 5000’ over N.A. zone.  Bursts from Lewis fired at one which dived.  Formation continued in a North Westerly direction climbing above clouds.

Vis. Fair.  Height 400/3000’. Obs by P.&.O.

Another lengthy Squadron Record Book (SRB) report, which is perhaps not surprising given the pace of events on the ground.  The distance covered on the ground was remarkable –  going east from Lille to the Escaut river, which flows north from Tournai some 4½ miles (7.5km) to the east of the Belgian border.  To put this in context, Tournai is almost as far to the east of Lille (15 miles, 24 km) as Merville is to the west (18 miles, 29 km).  And it had taken quite some months to cover the ground from Merville to Lille.

It’s difficult to fit all these events on a map that’s large enough to see the detail (even when clicked).  So here’s a selection, on a map that shows the land between Lille, in France, and Tournai, in Belgium.

Map showing some of the observations on reconnaissance patrol on 18 October 1918
Map showing some of the observations on reconnaissance patrol on 18 October 1918. East of Lille to Tournai.  Adapted from a composite of 1:40,000 scale maps. Each numbered square is 1,000 yards. French-Belgian border position only approximate. Click for larger image. Map credit IWM/TNA/GreatWarDigital.

Large fires in woods along railway at I.31.c.

At 1250 Greg reported large fires in woods along a railway line, at I.31.c. The woods are between the villages of Fourcroix and Pont-à-Chin, northwest of Tournai.  This larger scale map extract shows them in better detail:

Map showing fire in woods at I.31.c, northwest of Tournai, on 18 October 1918.
Map showing fire in woods at I.31.c, northwest of Tournai, on 18 October 1918.  See below for the significance of the blue car. Adapted from a 1:40,000 scale map. Each numbered square is 1,000 yards. Click for larger image. Map credit IWM/TNA/GreatWarDigital.

The railway in question, incidentally, is the line running northwest from Tournai towards Kortrijk, just after the branch off west towards Lille.

The view of the woods today, looking from where the blue car is shown on the map, is this:

View of woods
The view looking north to the woods by the railway line where the fires were at I.31.c – complete with blue car.  If you tap or click to see a larger image, you should be able to make out the masts of the railway’s present day catenary system in front of the trees. 

The map reference of the car’s location, in First World War terms, is 35.O.1.a.7.3.  You can see the location today on Google Maps at https://goo.gl/maps/wkfzpNFVGeC2.  

Bursts from Lewis

According to the SRB, the Lewis gun fired bursts at one of the Fokker biplanes that were seen over zone N.A.  But if we believe Greg’s log book, the Vickers gun fired 100 rounds,  and the Lewis gun fired nothing.  It looks as though one of these entries is a mix up, but who can now tell which was right?

Back home to Chocques

From Pont-à-Chin on the River Escaut, north of Tournai, back to Chocques was 34 miles (55 km).  This is almost three times the distance from Merville to Rely, which was a frequent journey home for Greg not so many weeks ago. An indication that 42 Squadron will soon need to move again.

Farewell to E27

According to his log book, this was Greg’s final flight in E27, which had more or less been his usual machine.  (According to the Squadron Record Book, Greg flew E27 on a short travelling flight on 22 October 1918, which his log book records as having been in 2517.  But whichever is correct, both sources agree that this was his last war flying patrol in E27.)

E27’s History

E27 had been built by Siddeley-Deasy in Coventry in March 1918, as a gift from  the Chiefs of the Northern Shan States, Burma.  It was  despatched to the British Expeditionary Force (c/o No 1 Aeroplane Supply Depot (ASD), then at St Omer) the following month.  E27 was allocated to 42 Squadron on 11 April 1918 – three days after Greg had got his wings at Yatesbury:

Monday 8 April 1918 – RAF Graduation and First Solo in RE8

An RE8 named Gwen?

Greg had first flown E27 on 11 June 1918.  This was the occasion when he got hopelessly lost, and he landed at Bergues, near Dunkirk.  It was also when he wrote the name Gwen next to E27 in his diary.  Greg took up E27 most flying days since that day, until he went on leave on 18 September 1918.  But when he came back he only flew this aeroplane occasionally.  Today marked his 63rd flight in the aircraft. It was his final patrol, and possibly his last flight, in it. The records show that E27 was marked ‘time expired’ on 1 November 1918.  The squadron handed it back to No. 1 ASD (which by then had moved to Marquise, between Boulogne and Calais, and located more precisely here) on 8 November 1918.

Observers came and went, but E27 – whether named Gwen or not – was the nearest Greg had to a constant companion.  And in the end, the aircraft just wore out.  

Thanks to airhistory.org.uk for the history of E27.

RE8 Serial No E29
RE8 Serial No E29, a sister aircraft to E27, built at the same time (March 1918) by Siddeley-Deasy in Coventry. E29 was named Lamberhurst.  On the subject of RE8 names, it may be that E27 was named Gwen, possibly officially or just affectionately by Greg – see the post for 11 June 1918.  Click for larger image. Photo marked public domain by Wikipedia.

Meanwhile, in Lille…

More British troops entered Lille from the west. They got a warm reception, as these Imperial War Museum photographs show.  

Troops of the 8th Battalion, Liverpool Regiment (57th British Division, XI Corps), swarmed by local children, entering Lille, 18 October 1918.
THE HUNDRED DAYS OFFENSIVE, AUGUST-NOVEMBER 1918 (Q 9579) Troops of the 8th Battalion, Liverpool Regiment (57th British Division, XI Corps), swarmed by local children, entering Lille, 18 October 1918. The soldier carrying a Lewis machine gun is Private Arthur John O’Hare 307465. Click for larger image. Copyright: © IWM. Original Source: http://www.iwm.org.uk/collections/item/object/205222941
Troops of the 8th Battalion, the King's (Liverpool Regiment, Liverpool Irish, 57th Division) entering Lille, 18 October 1918.
THE HUNDRED DAYS OFFENSIVE, AUGUST-NOVEMBER 1918 (Q 9572) Troops of the 8th Battalion, the King’s (Liverpool Regiment, Liverpool Irish, 57th Division) entering Lille, 18 October 1918. Click for larger image. Copyright: © IWM. Original Source: http://www.iwm.org.uk/collections/item/object/205245317
Troops of the 57th and 59th Divisions (probably of the 8th Battalion, Liverpool Regiment), swarmed by local children and decorated with flowers, entering Lille, 18 October 1918.
THE HUNDRED DAYS OFFENSIVE, AUGUST-NOVEMBER 1918 (Q 9575) Troops of the 57th and 59th Divisions (probably of the 8th Battalion, Liverpool Regiment), swarmed by local children and decorated with flowers, entering Lille, 18 October 1918. Click for larger image. Copyright: © IWM. Original Source: http://www.iwm.org.uk/collections/item/object/205245320
Troops of the 8th Battalion, the King's (Liverpool Regiment, Liverpool Irish, 57th Division) entering Lille, 18 October 1918
THE HUNDRED DAYS OFFENSIVE, AUGUST-NOVEMBER 1918 (Q 9574) Troops of the 8th Battalion, the King’s (Liverpool Regiment, Liverpool Irish, 57th Division) entering Lille, 18 October 1918. Note a barefooted French boy with a rifle, clearly given to him by a smiling soldier on his right. Click for larger image. Copyright: © IWM. Original Source: http://www.iwm.org.uk/collections/item/object/205245319
Troops of the 8th Battalion, the King's (Liverpool Regiment, Liverpool Irish, 57th Division) entering the outskirts of Lille, 18 October 1918.
THE HUNDRED DAYS OFFENSIVE, AUGUST-NOVEMBER 1918 (Q 9580) Troops of the 8th Battalion, the King’s (Liverpool Regiment, Liverpool Irish, 57th Division) entering the outskirts of Lille, 18 October 1918. Click for larger image. Copyright: © IWM. Original Source: http://www.iwm.org.uk/collections/item/object/205232604

Next up…

Greg’s next log book entry is for Tuesday 22 October 1918.

Thursday 17 October 1918 – Flying East of Liberated Lille

Today was the day of the liberation of Lille. It was a momentous day for the populace, when the British Fifth Army under General Birdwood entered the city. It was also significant day for Greg:  he records for the first time that he was reconnoitring east of Lille, near and around the Fort du Vinage.  He noted the destructive trail left by the withdrawing German army, and he reported the newly established German line south of Roubaix.

Log Book

Log Book

Date: 17.10.18 
Time Out: 14.10 
Rounds Fired – Lewis: - 
Rounds Fired – Vickers: - 
Bombs: - 
Time on RE8s:  173 hrs 35 mins 
RE8: E27 
Observer: Scarterfield 
War Flying: 2 hrs 15 mins 
Height: 2000 
Course/Remarks:  Reconn.  5000x E of Lille

5000x E of Lille

There is a bit of a puzzle in the log book entry: what does the x denote? 

The first issue is what letter it actually is.  I have transcribed it as a superscripted ‘x’, as that seems to me to be the most likely option.  But it could, just conceivably, be a ‘t’.  But in that case, what might a ‘t’ stand for?  From the Squadron Record Book (SRB), extracted below, we can establish definitively that it doesn’t mean British troops. The entry clearly states: “No British troops seen East of Lille”.  And although German troops east of Lille would be unremarkable, the SRB merely refers to a “few odd German infantry with civilians on road…”  The same reasoning would also rule out tanks (if the quantity of 5,000 hadn’t ruled them out anyway).

But in any event, the superscript looks more like an ‘x’ than a ‘t’.  And it is hard to think of a plausible word beginning with an ‘x’ that it might stand for.  

So what else might ‘x’ mean?

Might it indicate height?  5,000 ft is certainly a reasonable height for an RE8 to fly at.  But on this occasion both the log book and the SRB tell us that Greg flew no higher than 2,000 ft.  So that’s not it.

My working hypothesis is that ‘x’ indicates distance, specifically yards, on the ground.  The maps that Greg was working with all had numbered 1,000 yard sub-squares, within 6,000 yard lettered squares.  (See the article on Counter-Battery Patrols for an explanation of how the map reference system worked.)  So pilots would be well used to gauging distances in 1,000 yard units.  Given the locations that Greg reported on in that patrol (from the SRB again), it is likely that he was flying some five map sub-squares east of Lille, which is to say 5,000 yards east of the city.  But even if this is the correct explanation, I don’t know why he wrote ‘5000x‘ and not ‘5000 yds’.  Any suggestions or alternative explanations welcome.

Squadron Record Book

Squadron Record Book

Squadron Record Book
Squadron Record Book. Click for larger image.
Type and Number: R.E.8.27
Pilot and Observer: P. Lt Gregory. O. Lt Scarterfield
Duty: Reconnaissance
Hour of Start: 1410
Hour of Return: 1625
Remarks: FIRES at the following places:-
Farm F.25.d.4.5
Houses K.6.a.4.6
Factory Q.1.b.0.4
   "    K.20.d.5.0
   "    K.15.central.)
   "    K.2.c.0.5    ) Commenced during patrol.

Enemy trench system in wood at L.22.a.&.b. apparently unoccupied; full of water.
Few odd German Infantry with civilians on road L.15.d.& L.16.a.
BRIDGE destroyed at:-
Railway over road at L.13.d.4.5.
   "     "    "      K.24.d.6.4.
   "     "    "      K.23.d.9.3.
   "     "    "      K.22.b.6.9.

All bridges and locks on Eastern water defences [see below] of LILLE destroyed.
EXPLOSIONS at:-
1534. K.5.c.6.8. (Apparently dump)
1535. F.26.a.Central.

Large fires burning in LANNOY and on Eastern outskirts of ROUBAIX.
Bridges along river from L.9 to L.29 all destroyed.
Forts BABYLON, du VINAGE, & de MONS [en BAROEUL] occupied lightly by patrols.
Fired at with rifles from FORT DU VINAGE. [see below]
1530. Two civilians at Fort roads [sic: cross-roads?] at K.18.central, proceeding from direction of ROUBAIX to LILLE.
No British troops seen East of LILLE.
Enemy outposts appear to be holding a line roughly running though L.16, R.10 & X.5.  Few odd patrols & civilians seen W. of this line.

A.A. Vigorous burst of accurate A.A. fire over L.24. & L.29 at 1525.
Vis poor.  Height 400/2000’.  Obs by P.&.O.

This lengthy Squadron Record Book entry confirms that the action was shifting to the east of the city by mid-afternoon.  Much infrastructure had visibly been destroyed by the withdrawing German army.  It was a remarkable day, given that it had started with the British front line being some 4½ miles (7 km) northwest of Lille, towards Armentières:

Map of British Front west of Lille on the morning of 17 October 1918
The British Front west of Lille on the morning of 17 October 1918. By the afternoon, the city would be liberated. Adapted from a map accompanying General Haig’s despatches on the final British offensive. Click for larger image. Map credit: IWM/TNA/GreatWarDigital

And here, on a larger scale map, are some of the locations mentioned in the SRB entry for the mid-afternoon reconnaissance patrol undertaken by Greg and Lt Scarterfield:

Map showing observations on reconnaissance patrol on 17 October 1918.
Map showing observations on reconnaissance patrol on 17 October 1918. Adapted from a 1:40,000 scale map. Each numbered square is 1,000 yards. Click for larger image. Map credit IWM/TNA/GreatWarDigital.

Fort du Vinage, and Anti-Aircraft Fire

Greg says that he was fired at with rifles from the Fort du Vinage (also known as the Fort du Haut Vinage).  He can’t have been flying too far from it to see this happening.  Fort du Vinage is about five sub-squares (5,000 yards) east of the centre of Lille. 

Also, he reports a “vigorous burst of accurate A.A. [anti-aircraft] fire over L.24. & L.29 at 1525”.  Those sub-squares are about five sub-squares east of Mons-en-Baroeul, on the easternmost outskirts of the city.

These points support the idea that the ‘5000x‘ in the log book is a reference to 5,000 yds east of Lille.

Bridges on Eastern Water Defences Destroyed

The old city of Lille was surrounded by water.  Over the last hundred years, Lille has expanded greatly.  The southern and eastern water defences of the old city have been filled in and are the course of Autoroutes that form part of the city’s boulevard périphérique.  The northern part of the old eastern water defences now also accommodates the high speed rail line from Calais and London and is the site of Lille Europe station (“Lilleurope” as they announce it on the Eurostar trains).  Both the tracks at this point and the station are underground.

Map of Lille in the First World War.
Lille in the First World War, from a 1:40,000 scale map. Each numbered square is 1,000 yards. Click for larger image. Map credit IWM/TNA/GreatWarDigital.
Map of Central Lille today.
Central Lille today, from 1:25,000 scale map re-scaled to match the First World War map above. Click for larger image. Map credit IGN France/GreatWarDigital.

The German Line

Greg records that “Enemy outposts appear to be holding a line roughly running though L.16, R.10 & X.5”.  This line runs more or less due south from Roubaix, some 4 miles (6.5km) east of the centre of Lille.  It passes through Anappes and Sainghin.  Annappes is now part of Villeneuve-d’Ascq, which is itself part of the Lille-Roubaix-Tourcoing conurbation.  Sainghin (today Sainghin-en-Mélantois) is just near the important high speed rail junction southeast of Lille, where the lines from Paris, Brussels and London all meet. 

Lille from the Air

Greg had a couple of aerial photographs of Lille in his collection.  They are unmarked and undated, so it is hard to know when they were taken.  But it is likely to have been today or later, given the occupation of the city beforehand.  Possibly they were taken after the armistice.  But in any event here they are, with corresponding contemporary views from Google maps:

Vertical aerial view of Lille in 1918 - Flandres Station and Théâtre
Vertical aerial view of Lille in 1918, showing Lille Flandres station (bottom right) and what was then the Théâtre de Lille, now the Opéra de Lille (centre left). Click for larger image. Photo credit: Greg’s War Collection.
Contemporary vertical aerial view of Lille.
The same aerial view today, courtesy of Google. The new Lille Europe station is off the field to the top right.  Click for link to Google maps.
Oblique aerial view of Lille in 1918
Slightly oblique aerial view of Lille in 1918, showing the city centre and the Place de la République (bottom centre left) Click for larger image. Photo credit: Greg’s War Collection.
Contemporary oblique aerial view of Lille.
The same aerial view today, courtesy of Google. Click for link to Google maps.

It is evident from the two 1918 photographs that, although knocked about, Lille did not suffer physical destruction to anything like the same extent as Ypres, some 17 miles (27 km) away to the northwest.  The contrast with the aerial photographs in the following post for 28 September 1918 is quite telling:

Saturday 28 September 1918 – Ypres

 Liberation of Lille…and Elsewhere

Liberation was in the air, and not only in Lille.  In this newly published article, Michael Seymour explains what it meant for the people of Lille and elsewhere:

Liberation of Lille…and Elsewhere

Monday 14 October 1918 – First CBP from Chocques

On their first day at their base at Chocques, 42 Squadron’s aircraft are back at work.  Greg is assigned with Lt Bett to an afternoon counter-battery patrol in the same aircraft that he ferried over from Rely yesterday.  They were working around Englos and Sequedin, west of Lille. But they had to cut the patrol short.  This was because the weather was poor, and the engine was missing badly.

Log Book

Log BookLog Book

Date: 14.10.18 
Time Out: 14.15 
Rounds Fired – Lewis: - 
Rounds Fired – Vickers: 100 
Bombs: 4 
Time on RE8s:  171 hrs 20 mins 
RE8: 6740 
Observer: Bett 
War Flying: 1 hr 50 mins 
Height: 3000 
Course/Remarks:  C.B.P.

Squadron Record Book

Squadron Record Book
Squadron Record Book. Click for larger image.
Type and Number: R.E.8.6740
Pilot and Observer: P. Lt Gregory. O. Lt Bett
Duty: Artillery Patrol
Hour of Start: 1415.
Hour of Return: 1605.
Remarks: No flashes seen, possibly owing to poor visibility.
1500. Fire (buildings) burning for a few minutes at P.13.c.5.9. [Hallenes-lez-Haubourdin]
Broad belts of wire protecting trenches in P.4.b. & 5.a. [Le Marais] 
Unable to observe any train activity owing to mist.
Early return due to engine missing badly.
A.A. active.  A.A.M.G. [anti-aircraft machine guns] active from O.5. & O.6. [Ennetières-en-Weppe] 
E.A. Nil
E.K.B. Nil.
BOMBS. 1445. 4- 25lb dropped in O.12.d. [Moulin Joyeux] Four bursts observed.
100.V.G. fired from 2000’ into FORT d’ENGLOS.
Vis. Poor.  Height 2000’.  Obs. by P.&.O.

Englos and Sequedin

All this activity was around Englos and Sequedin, just to the west of Lille:

Map showing observations on counter battery patrol
Map showing observations on counter battery patrol. Adapted from a 1:40,000 scale map. Each numbered square is 1,000 yards. Click for larger image. Map credit IWM/TNA/GreatWarDigital.

Today, between Englos and Sequedin there is a major autoroute junction on the A25, which runs from Dunkirk to Lille

Yet again, Fort d’Englos was on the receiving end of the RE8’s weapons, as on 8 October 1918 and 5 October 1918.  Evidently it was still being used as a garrison site and ammunition depot.

In the end, engine trouble caused Greg and Lt Bett to go home early.  At least the journey back to Chocques was 10 miles (16 km) shorter than it would have been to Rely.

Small Gain at Wavrin on the Front Line

The British Front Line, which ran more or less north-south just to the east of Armentières, had not moved much since 7 October 1918.  An exception was a small salient encompassing a railway junction near the small settlement of Wavrin:

British Front gain at Wavrin at 14 October 1918.
The British Front east of Armentières showing the small salient gained at Wavrin by 14 October 1918. Adapted from a map accompanying General Haig’s despatches on the final British offensive. Click for larger image. Map credit: IWM/TNA/GreatWarDigital

A small gain, but possibly a significant one. Gaining the junction meant that British troops now controlled the railway running just behind the front from La Basée to Armentières. No doubt very useful logistically.  

Next up…

Greg’s next log book entry is for 17 October 1918.

© Copyright 2018- Andrew Sheard and licensors. All rights reserved.